Free $30 eGift card with your $100 order

Small Pet Select Orchard Grass Hay Small Animal Food, 10-lb box

Skip image gallery
Slide 1 of 9
$22.74 First Time Autoship Price
this order
Save 35% (up to $20) today when you set up Autoship. 
$33.24 Autoship Price
(-5%) future orders
  • Keep saving 5% on every order
  • Get deliveries on your schedule
  • Skip, change, or cancel anytime
$34.99 Chewy Price
($3.50 /lb)
Promo, New Customers Only: Spend $49+, get $20 eGift Card + free shipping with code WELCOME
In Stock
FREE delivery on first-time orders over $35
Arrives between Jul 18 and Jul 21
Free 365-day returns

No Interest if paid in full in 6 months on PayPal purchases of $149+. .

About This Item

Details

  • Hand-packed in small batches using only the highest quality, 100% US-grown, orchard grass hay—a great alternative for pet parents with timothy hay allergies.
  • Soft, delectable treat includes lots of munchable grass hay with very little stem or seed head and has a great mix of protein, fiber, and fat.
  • Each package is shipped in an earth-friendly, high-strength, corrugated box for easy storage.
  • Fresh from the farm hay helps wear down growing teeth and protects digestive health—perfect for rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas.
  • This orchard grass hay has a low amount of dust and comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Ingredient Information

Feeding Instructions

Frequently bought together

Questions & Answers

1 Customer Questions

Do you carry pet select hay 2nd cut

Answer by Michelle • Jun 29, 2022
No they don’t. I have asked them numerous times to carry it as it’s the healthiest option for rabbits.
Reviews
Write a Review
4.4
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
265 Ratings
Terms & Conditions

135 Customer Reviews

Rated 3 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Dana on Mar 4, 2026

had a few iffy boxes lately

this hay used to be really good and my rabbits love the orchard grass but the last few orders it’s been mostly brown pieces and my rabbits will pick those out and

this hay used to be really good and my rabbits love the orchard grass but the last few orders it’s been mostly brown pieces and my rabbits will pick those out and won’t eat them. that sucks because i’m going through it faster since they’re only eating half of what i give them and wasting the other half. hoping it improves soon or i’ll have to switch to something else

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Joanne on Jun 1, 2025

Horrible Hay

I’ve used SPS before. I have ordered it from you for quite some time. All the other 20lb boxes were as expexted BUT the his box was HORRIBLE! I know SPS gets their

I’ve used SPS before. I have ordered it from you for quite some time. All the other 20lb boxes were as expexted BUT the his box was HORRIBLE! I know SPS gets their hay from different parts of the country. I will have to buy a new box somewhere. The top of the box looked great. Nice green color UNTIL I put my hands in grabbing hay for their hay bucket. I yelled loud bc I was stuck by something. I called my husband in and his face said it all. I am sending a picture of my hay bucket so you can see it and of the hard hard pieces. Is there a way to ck the origin of the last box? The don’t want the same one. I do want orchard hay just not where that was cultivated.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By shawn on Jun 12, 2024

Brown hay instead of green

I’m sure not Chewy’s fault but this Pet Select hay is 1/2 really brown. I have pick through it & throw a lot of it away before giving it to my rabbit. It’s too much

I’m sure not Chewy’s fault but this Pet Select hay is 1/2 really brown. I have pick through it & throw a lot of it away before giving it to my rabbit. It’s too much work because it’s mixed. Pet Select should be ashamed of their quality! It was a good price through Chewy but not if I have to throw 1/2 of the hay out! I think I’ll stick to buying the Kaytee brand in the big box at Farm & Fleet. Way better quality! I don’t want to make my rabbit sick. I didn’t notice all the brown hay because I didn’t open it right away. I still had previous hay left. My mistake

Rated 3 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Hyunibee on Oct 21, 2021
Top 1000 Contributor

Crumbs in 20 Lbs boxes, but too expensive to order 2 10lb boxes

The hay is generally clean and fresh, with long strands. However, in the past year, I've noticed a lot of hay crush when ordering the 20lb boxes. The top layer is

The hay is generally clean and fresh, with long strands. However, in the past year, I've noticed a lot of hay crush when ordering the 20lb boxes. The top layer is beautiful, but then 40-60% of the rest of the box is all crumbs and strands shorter than 3". If the price of 2 10lb-boxes was comparable to the 20lb-box, I would order them because I don't see the same crumbly issue with the smaller boxes.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Karen on May 23, 2025

Too many dust

My recent two orders were full of dust , very short length hays and dry brown ones which guinea pigs can’t eat. More than one third from the box. Hopefully the company

My recent two orders were full of dust , very short length hays and dry brown ones which guinea pigs can’t eat. More than one third from the box. Hopefully the company improves checking the quality before shipping out to the customers.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Sydney on Mar 23, 2026

Best hay available!

When Oxbow hay started having super low quality, I searched for a reasonably priced brand with good reviews. Small Pet Select has definitely been better than Oxbow

When Oxbow hay started having super low quality, I searched for a reasonably priced brand with good reviews. Small Pet Select has definitely been better than Oxbow. My rabbits won’t eat the small bits of hay, and the Oxbow hay was that completely. My bunnies love it so much that I will fill up their hay bags at night and they will be empty in the morning.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Nikki on May 29, 2026

Too expensive for the poor quality

I tried this brand after the 50lb box of Oxbow went out of stock thinking it would be better quality since it costs more.... but no, it wasn't worth the extra cost

I tried this brand after the 50lb box of Oxbow went out of stock thinking it would be better quality since it costs more.... but no, it wasn't worth the extra cost. It was still really dusty and it had more small twigs than my last Oxbow purchase. There was also a lot of feathers scattered in throughout the whole box. I'll just go back to using Oxbow even though I'm still not happy about paying more for a smaller box than I was before.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By ariggs on Oct 1, 2020

Amazing quality.

Let me start by saying this is green!! I could smell the hay through the chewy box upon arrival. I am extremely happy with this purchase. And my rabbit seems to

Let me start by saying this is green!! I could smell the hay through the chewy box upon arrival. I am extremely happy with this purchase. And my rabbit seems to enjoy the hay so far! Will definitely be my staple hay purchase!

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Mavis on Sep 14, 2025

Love them but not consistent quality

I do love it when it's so green it's turquoise and soft to the touch. But the lack of consistency is disappointing. Sometimes it's dry and prickly to the touch with

I do love it when it's so green it's turquoise and soft to the touch. But the lack of consistency is disappointing. Sometimes it's dry and prickly to the touch with faded green and brown colors. It should be the least of my worries to count on consistency gorgeous green orchard grass.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
By Aaliyah on Apr 6, 2023

Straw. It's straw.

The first box we got was great :/ The second box was 30% straw, and my bunny has yet to eat a single piece of any of it. I opened the box in dim light but almost

The first box we got was great :/ The second box was 30% straw, and my bunny has yet to eat a single piece of any of it. I opened the box in dim light but almost immediately could tell it was wrong by the texture. It's super dry and stiff and I have to pick out huge clumps of hard useless grass. Ironically they put a postcard on top of the box this time :( it feels bad, man. Like a taunt.