Puppy Chow Healthy Start Salmon Flavor Training Dog Treats, 24-oz pouch

We have ordered this product many times. All the products have been excellent. I cannot criticize Chewy about anything! Products, quality, prices, nothing! Skye has been on Blue lamb and rice since we brought her home at three years old. Through Chewy we can have deliverd to our front door cheaper than picking it up anywhere.

I filI filled out a return on an expired package, and it was wonderful. Now my second auto-ship order has the same thing, expired treats. I hate to keep complaining. I ordered four packages of treats, two outdated and two good. I’m not sure if it’s because it was at the end of the year and the start of a new year, but I’ve never had this kind of problem with an expired package of treats. 'Chewy, replace them immediately.'

My pup enjoys the taste of these, but since she is very small at 5.5 lbs, 3 calories every time she does something correct during a training session is actually quite a lot. These also aren't actually very soft, and quite difficult to split in two like they are intended. My finger actually got callused from splitting these because they are so hard, and it doesn't seem worth the trouble but I also don't want to waste them. I notice they are slightly easier to split if room temperature is warmer. But it's the middle of winter, and a lot of training sessions are outside and my house is always colder in winter. I would suggest not getting these if the ability to split them easily is important to you, and maybe use these for training treats for a larger puppy. On a positive note, my pup did like the taste and these helped her get used to wearing her cone after surgery.

I'm using these as rewards in the potty training adventure. The puppies love them and make sure I'm watching when they do their business. Only reason they get a 4 instead of a 5 is that they harden up after you take them out of the package, making it difficult to break them in half. For tiny guys I wish they broke easier.