Treats for New Cats

Sort
Filter
Out of Stock

Natural Pet Pals Cool Catnip, 1-oz bag

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
2

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 2 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 3 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 4 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 5 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 6 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 7 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 2 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 3 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 4 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 5 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 6 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 7 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 2 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 3 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 4 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 5 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 6 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 7 of 7
Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Salmon & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz t...

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
27

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 2 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 3 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 4 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 5 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 6 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 7 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 2 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 3 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 4 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 5 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 6 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 7 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 1 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 2 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 3 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 4 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 5 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 6 of 7
Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, 4 count slide 7 of 7
Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Chicken & Duck Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tub...

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
28

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Slide 1 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 1 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 2 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 3 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 4 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 5 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 6 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 7 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 8 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 1 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 2 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 3 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 4 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 5 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 6 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 7 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 8 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 1 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 2 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 3 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 4 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 5 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 6 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 7 of 8
Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count slide 8 of 8
Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Inaba Churu Bisque for Cats Chicken Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treats, 1.05-oz pouch, 15 count

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
197

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

PureBites Ocean Whitefish Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Treats, 0.7-oz bag

Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
469

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Inaba Churu Grain-Free Chicken with Scallop Puree Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tube, pack of 4

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
429

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Inaba Churu Stew Chicken Variety Cat Lickable Treat, 1.4-oz pouch, 12 count

Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
83

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Lucy Pet Products Kitty Lickies Sardine & Tuna Recipe Grain-Free Lickable Cat Treat, 0.5-oz tub...

Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
28

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Temptations Meaty Bites Chicken Flavor Soft & Savory Cat Treats, 4.12-oz bag

Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
1,752

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Meowee! Savory Spoonables Triple Flavor Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treat, Squeezable Tube, 12 co...

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
127

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Wildly Natural Salmon Flavor Cat Treats, 2.5-oz bag

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
309

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Primal Liver, Laugh, Love for Cats! Simply Pork Flavored Crunchy Cat Treats, 1.5-oz bag

Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
50

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Bravo! Healthy Medleys Mariner's Medley Limited Ingredient Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Treats, 0.75-oz...

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
40

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Bravo! Healthy Bites Salmon Single Ingredient Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Treats, 1-oz bag

Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
93

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Tiny Tiger Lickables Stew Chicken & Tuna Recipe Cat Treat & Topper, 1.4-oz pouch, case of 12

By
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
122

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Bravo! Healthy Bites Chicken Breast Single Ingredient Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Treats, 1.25-oz bag

Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
80

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Out of Stock

Loading options...

Loading options...

Tiny Tiger Lickables Stew Tuna & Whitefish Recipe Cat Treat & Topper, 1.4-oz pouch, case of 12

By
Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
128

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Category

Crunchy Treats

Soft & Chewy Treats

Lickable Treats

Catnip & Pet Grass

Freeze-Dried & Dehydrated

Save 5% on repeat deliveries

Product Type

Product Category

Brand

7 Brands are shown below

Lifestage

Price

Customer Rating