Plush & Mice Toys for New Cats

Sort
Filter
Slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 2 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 3 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 4 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 2 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 3 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 4 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 2 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 3 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 4 of 4
Slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 2 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 3 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 4 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 2 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 3 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 4 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 1 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 2 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 3 of 4
Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count slide 4 of 4

Quirky Kitty Avocado Toast Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
32
$8.00 Chewy Price
($4.00/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 2 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 3 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 4 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 5 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 6 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 7 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 2 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 3 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 4 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 5 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 6 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 7 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 2 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 3 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 4 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 5 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 6 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 7 of 7
Slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 2 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 3 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 4 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 5 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 6 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 7 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 2 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 3 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 4 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 5 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 6 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 7 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 1 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 2 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 3 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 4 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 5 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 6 of 7
Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys slide 7 of 7

Fashion's Talk Mouse 27 Piece Assorted Mice Toy Cat Toys

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
22
$14.88 Chewy Price
($0.56/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Slide 1 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 1 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 2 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 3 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 4 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 5 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 6 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 1 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 2 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 3 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 4 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 5 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 6 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 1 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 2 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 3 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 4 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 5 of 6
Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip slide 6 of 6

Frisco Easter Bunny & Detachable Carrot Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Catnip

By
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
93
$9.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Slide 1 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 1 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 2 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 3 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 4 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 5 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 1 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 2 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 3 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 4 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 5 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 1 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 2 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 3 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 4 of 5
Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox slide 5 of 5

Frisco Plush Kicker Cat Toy, Orange Fox

By
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
1,667
$5.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Hummingbird Chirping Sound Electronic Plush Cat Toy with Catnip

By
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
876
$5.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Skinny Mouse Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, Gray

By
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
1,696
$5.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

FuzzYard Chakra Plush Cat Toy with Catnip

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
30
$5.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Avocado Dangly Plush Cat Toy with Catnip

By
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
546
$5.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Yeowww! Pineapple Cat Toy, Assorted Colors

Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
136
$11.12 Chewy Price
$11.69 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Catstages Peelin' Good Banana Kicker Dental Cat Plush Toy with Catnip, Yellow

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
40
$6.49 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Sushi Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 4 count

By
Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
2,195
$12.99 Chewy Price
($3.25/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Quirky Kitty House Plant Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
26
$5.48 Chewy Price
($2.74/ea) Price per Unit
$7.49 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

New

Frisco Coastal Seahorse Jumbo Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Silvervine & Catnip

By
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
17
$8.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Taco Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 2 count

By
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
228
$7.99 Chewy Price
($4.00/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Mad Cat 100% Filled Kitty Carrot Cat Mice Plush Toy with Catnip, Multi Color, Medium

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
75
$8.49 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Donut Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 2 count

By
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
394
$7.99 Chewy Price
($4.00/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Sardine Jumbo Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Silvervine & Catnip

By
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
25
$6.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Halloween Frankenstein Boo Basket Variety Pack Cat Toy with Silvervine & Catnip, 15 coun...

By
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
74
$24.99 Chewy Price
($1.67/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Magic Familiars Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 3 count

By
Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
233
$9.99 Chewy Price
($3.33/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Yeowww! Kitten Mittens Cat Toy, 3 count

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
28
$13.96 Chewy Price
($4.66/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Mouse Cat Toy with Catnip, Bright Neutral Multicolor, 10 count

By
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
771
$11.99 Chewy Price
($1.20/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Winter Sports Americana Variety Pack Cat Toy with Silvervine & Catnip, 12 count

By
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
24
$11.99 Chewy Price
($1.00/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Quirky Kitty Whisker Claw Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
110
$5.48 Chewy Price
($2.74/ea) Price per Unit
$7.49 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Hartz Cattraction Crinkle Mice Cat Toy, Multi Color, 10 count

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
124
$13.89 Chewy Price
($1.39/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Road Trip Traffic Signs Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 4 count

By
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
40
$12.99 Chewy Price
($3.25/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Yeowww! Sun, Moon & Stars Cat Toy, 3 count

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
24
$14.44 Chewy Price
($4.82/ea) Price per Unit
$15.88 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Mad Cat Gnome Sweet Gnome Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy, 2 count

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
57
$11.98 Chewy Price
($5.99/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Magic Fortune Teller Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 2 count

By
Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
50
$7.99 Chewy Price
($4.00/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Bundle: Sheba Meaty Tender Sticks Tuna Flavored Cat Treats, 5 count + Frisco Refillable Catnip ...
By
Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
49
$7.97 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Valentine Jammin' Ladybug Plush Cat Toy with Catnip

By
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
87
$6.99 Chewy Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Magic Potions Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 2 count

By
Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
116
$7.99 Chewy Price
($4.00/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Catstages Garden Fur-ends Plush Catnip Cat Toy, Multicolor, 6 count

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
45
$8.99 Chewy Price
($1.50/ea) Price per Unit
$13.99 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Bundle and Save 5%
Bundle: Frisco Cactus Scratching Post, 22-in + Plush Dangly Avocado Buddy Cat Toy with Catnip
By
Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
66
$29.81 Chewy Price
$31.38 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Quirky Kitty Meowgarita Time Catnip Plush Cat Toy, 2 count

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
40
$6.99 Chewy Price
($3.50/ea) Price per Unit
$7.49 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Yeowww! Chi-CAT-a Banana Peeled Cat Toy, Assorted Colors

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
105
$11.94 Chewy Price
$11.99 List Price
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Frisco Holiday Lumps of Coal Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 3 count

By
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
224
$11.99 Chewy Price
($4.00/ea) Price per Unit
Autoship Price

Free 1-3 day delivery on first-time orders over $35
Free 365-day returns

Save 5% on repeat deliveries

Product Type

Product Category

Brand

7 Brands are shown below

Lifestage

Breed Size

Price

Customer Rating